nextdoor
buy propane tank costco

A Smart Shopper’s Guide to Propane Tanks

If you’re looking to buy a propane tank, you’re in the right place. Here’s what you need to know:

Quick Answer: Buying and Refilling Propane Tanks

  • Refill vs. Exchange: Understand the difference between refilling your own tank and exchanging it for a pre-filled one to maximize value.
  • Price Advantage: Refilling is often cheaper per gallon, as you only pay for the propane you need.
  • Tank Requirements: To be refilled, your tank must be unexpired (under 12 years old from its manufacture date) and in safe condition.
  • Service Locations: Not all retailers that sell propane offer on-site refill services; it’s best to check beforehand.
  • Safety First: You are responsible for your tank’s overall safety, as attendants typically only verify the expiration date.

Whether you’re grilling up burgers for the family or keeping your patio heater running through cool Charleston evenings, propane is an essential fuel. Many shoppers have found that understanding the difference between refilling and exchanging can lead to significant savings. The catch? Knowing how the system works and what your responsibilities are as a tank owner.

This guide breaks down everything you need to know about purchasing and refilling propane tanks—from choosing the right size tank to understanding your responsibilities for tank safety and maintenance. We’ll cover pricing considerations, the refill process, tank lifespan regulations, and the key differences between refilling and exchanging that could save you money in the long run.

The helpful team at Lowcountry Ace has extensive experience helping Charleston-area customers with their propane needs, from selecting the right tank size to understanding safety requirements when you buy a propane tank. We’re here to help you make informed decisions about your grilling and outdoor heating fuel needs.

Infographic showing the complete propane tank buying and refilling process: starting with membership requirement, showing price comparison between warehouse club ($72.99 for 30lb tank) versus manufacturer ($84.95), illustrating the refill-only service model with no exchanges, displaying the 12-year tank lifespan timeline with recertification option at year 12 for 5 additional years, and highlighting key safety checkpoints including expiration date verification and owner responsibility for tank condition - buy propane tank costco infographic roadmap-5-steps

Easy buy propane tank glossary:

Understanding Your Propane Tank Options

When you set out to buy a propane tank, you’ll quickly realize that not all tanks are created equal. The world of propane tanks offers a variety of sizes and features, each suited for different applications, from a quick camping trip to powering your outdoor kitchen. At their core, most propane tanks you’ll find are high-grade steel cylinders built for durability and safety.

Various propane tanks in different sizes, including 1 lb, 5 lb, 20 lb, and 100 lb, for different uses - buy propane tank costco

Search Lowcountry Ace

Common tank sizes typically include:

  • 1 lb tanks: These small, portable cylinders are often sold in multi-packs and are ideal for camping stoves, lanterns, and portable grills.
  • 5 lb tanks: A step up in capacity, a 5 lb tank offers more fuel than a 1 lb tank but remains highly portable for camping, hiking, or small grilling needs. They often come with handy features like built-in gauges.
  • 20 lb tanks: This is arguably the most common size, perfect for home BBQ grills, patio heaters, and some smaller RV applications. It strikes a good balance between capacity and manageable weight.
  • 30 lb tanks: Slightly larger than the standard grill tank, 30 lb tanks are often used for RVs, larger patio heaters, or for those who grill frequently and want fewer refills.
  • 100 lb tanks: These are the giants of portable propane, used for whole-house heating, generators, or large commercial applications. They offer substantial fuel capacity and typically feature a POL valve.

Beyond size, key features to look for include:

  • Overflow Protection Device (OPD) valves: These are crucial safety devices that help prevent overfilling of propane tanks, which is a common cause of accidents. Most modern consumer-size tanks will have an OPD valve.
  • Built-in gauges: Some tanks, especially the 5 lb and 20 lb sizes, come with a built-in gauge, allowing you to easily monitor your propane levels and avoid running out unexpectedly mid-grill.
  • DOT approval: Always ensure any portable propane tank you purchase is DOT (Department of Transportation) approved. This signifies that the tank meets safety standards, having undergone testing for structural integrity.
  • Powder coating: A good powder-coated finish provides long-lasting exterior protection against rust and the elements, extending the life and appearance of your tank.

Choosing the Right Size for Your Needs

Selecting the correct propane tank size is all about matching capacity with your specific usage. For our friends in James Island, Folly Beach, and the wider Charleston area, knowing your primary use case will guide your decision.

  • 5 lb & 20 lb tanks: These are your go-to for standard backyard grilling and patio heaters. A 20 lb tank is the workhorse for most grills, while a 5 lb tank offers a more compact option for tailgating or smaller portable grills.
  • 30 lb & 100 lb tanks: If you have an RV, a larger outdoor kitchen setup, or need backup fuel for a generator, a 30 lb or even a 100 lb tank might be more appropriate. These larger tanks mean fewer trips for refills, which can be a significant convenience.

Consider the trade-off between portability and capacity. While a 100 lb tank offers immense fuel, it’s not something you’ll be casually moving around. A 5 lb tank, on the other hand, is easy to transport but will require more frequent refills.

The Real Cost: How to Buy a Propane Tank

One of the main reasons to be a savvy shopper when you need to buy a propane tank is the promise of significant savings. This often holds true, but there are a few key factors to understand, including how to find the best value.

Comparing the Cost to Buy a Propane Tank

For those of us in the Charleston area, the pricing for new propane tanks can be quite attractive if you know where to look. Prices for new, high-quality tanks are often competitive, and purchasing a new tank can be a smart long-term move.

This cost-effectiveness makes purchasing a new tank a great choice for many homeowners and grill masters.

Good retailers also tend to offer strong satisfaction guarantees on most merchandise, allowing you to shop with confidence, knowing you’re getting a good deal on a quality product.

If you choose to buy a propane tank online, the process is typically straightforward. Standard shipping via ground service is usually included or clearly shown in the quoted price, with delivery subject to carrier safety rules and restrictions.

Should you need to return an item purchased online, many retailers allow you to bring eligible items back to their physical locations for assistance, subject to their posted return policies. Always review the current return policy on the retailer’s website before purchasing.

Search Lowcountry Ace

For local, in-person help with selecting and safely using propane tanks and accessories, the helpful team at Lowcountry Ace is here for you in Charleston.

Refill Service: The Propane Process Explained

Beyond buying a new tank, a major consideration is how you’ll get your propane. Many consumers find that a refill service for their own tank offers distinct advantages over tank exchange programs.

A propane refill station at a warehouse club, showing a large tank and an attendant - buy propane tank costco

Advantages of Refilling Your Tank

When it comes to getting your propane, refilling often comes out on top compared to typical exchange services.

Feature Refilling Your Own Tank Typical Exchange Services
Cost-Effectiveness Usually lower per gallon; you only pay for the propane you receive. Often a flat fee, regardless of how much propane was left in your old tank.
Propane Quantity Tanks are typically filled to 80% capacity (the safe maximum). Exchange tanks might not be filled to 80%; sometimes less propane for the same price.
Tank Ownership You keep your own tank, ensuring you know its history and condition. You receive a different tank each time, which could be older or in poorer condition.
Leftover Gas No loss of leftover gas; you get credit for what’s already in your tank. Any leftover gas in your exchanged tank is lost.
Convenience Can often refill while doing other shopping. Quick swap, but may require a separate trip if not already at a retail location.

For our local community in Charleston, the cost savings can add up, especially if you’re a frequent griller or use propane for heating. Propane refill prices are usually competitive, making refills an economical choice. This means you’re getting more value by paying only for the fuel you need, up to the safe 80% capacity.

What to Know Before You Go

While the benefits are clear, there are important details to remember about the refill process:

  • Refill vs. Exchange: Some retailers only offer an exchange service, while others only offer refills. It’s important to confirm which service is available before you go.
  • Tank condition is your responsibility: While an attendant will check your tank, their primary focus will usually be on the expiration date. They do not perform comprehensive safety inspections or recertification. This means you are responsible for ensuring your tank is in good, safe working order.
  • Attendants typically check only the expiration date: If your tank is expired (more on this below), they will not refill it. This is a non-negotiable safety measure.
  • Finding refill services: Not every retailer that sells propane offers refills. It’s always a good idea to check a store’s website or call them directly before making the trip.
  • Payment process: Commonly, you’ll drop off your tank at the refill station, and after it’s filled, you’ll pay for the propane inside the store, according to that location’s procedures.

Understanding these nuances ensures a smooth experience when you head out to refill your propane tank.

Propane Tank Lifespan, Safety, and Maintenance

Propane tanks are incredibly durable, but they’re not immortal. Understanding your tank’s lifespan, how to maintain it, and crucial safety considerations are paramount, especially since the responsibility often falls on you, the owner.

Understanding Your Tank’s Lifespan and Recertification

A new propane tank’s lifespan is about 12 years from its manufacturing date. This is a critical piece of information because, for safety reasons, an expired tank cannot be refilled. The date of manufacture is stamped on the tank’s collar (the metal ring around the valve).

Propane tanks under 100 pounds capacity, like the common 20 lb grill tanks, have a maximum 12-year shelf life from the date of manufacturing, according to DOT regulations. Once this date passes, the tank is considered expired.

Search Lowcountry Ace

However, an expired tank doesn’t necessarily mean it’s trash! It can often be recertified. Recertification involves a thorough inspection by a qualified professional to ensure the tank is still structurally sound and safe for use. If it passes, the recertification can extend the tank’s service life by an additional five years. The important thing to remember is that many refill stations, while offering refills, do not offer recertification services. This is where local experts, like the helpful team at Lowcountry Ace, can provide guidance or direct you to local recertification facilities.

Key Safety Tips When You Buy a Propane Tank

Safety should always be your top priority when dealing with propane. Here are some essential tips:

  • Inspect for rust or dents: Before every use and especially before a refill, visually inspect your tank. Any significant rust, dents, or damage could compromise its integrity. If you notice any, it’s best to have it professionally inspected or replaced.
  • Ensure a functional OPD valve: As mentioned earlier, the Overflow Protection Device (OPD) valve is a crucial safety feature. Make sure it’s present and appears to be in good working order.
  • Transporting tanks safely: Always transport propane tanks upright in a secure position in your vehicle, preferably in the open air of a truck bed or with windows open. Never leave a tank in a closed, hot vehicle.
  • Storing tanks outdoors: Store propane tanks outdoors in a well-ventilated area, away from direct sunlight, heat sources, and ignition sources. Never store them indoors or in a garage.
  • Your responsibility for tank safety: Because attendants often only check the expiration date, the onus is on you to ensure your tank is safe. This includes regular visual inspections and understanding when your tank needs recertification or replacement.

By being diligent about these safety measures, you can enjoy the convenience and savings of propane with peace of mind.

Frequently Asked Questions about Propane Tanks

We often hear similar questions from our customers in the Charleston area about buying and refilling propane tanks. Let’s address some of the most common ones.

Do I need a membership to shop at Lowcountry Ace?

No, you do not need a membership to shop with us. At Lowcountry Ace, we welcome everyone in our community to come in for new propane tanks, refills, and expert advice without any membership fees. So, before you head out to buy a propane tank, know that our doors are open to all.

Do attendants inspect or recertify old propane tanks?

No, attendants at propane refill stations will generally only check the expiration date on your tank. They do not perform safety inspections beyond this basic visual check, nor do they offer recertification services. You are solely responsible for ensuring your tank is safe to use and properly certified. This means you need to be aware of your tank’s condition and its manufacturing date, and seek professional help for recertification when needed. The helpful team at Lowcountry Ace can guide you on safe propane usage and where to find additional services locally in the Charleston area.

Can I exchange my empty propane tank?

Some retailers operate strictly as a refill service and do not offer a propane tank exchange program. You must bring your own existing, unexpired tank to be filled. If you’re specifically looking for an exchange option, you will need to confirm availability with the retailer you plan to visit.

Conclusion

Navigating propane tanks, whether you’re looking to buy a propane tank or simply refill your existing one, can offer significant savings and convenience for our Lowcountry community. Choosing to refill your own tank is often a cost-effective option that beats many exchange programs.

However, this convenience comes with key responsibilities for you, the tank owner. Understanding your tank’s lifespan, diligently checking its manufacturing date, and being aware that you are responsible for its overall safety and condition are crucial. While many places will refill an unexpired tank, they do not offer comprehensive safety inspections or recertification services.

For expert advice on tank safety checks, choosing the right tank size, or finding the right accessories for your grill and outdoor needs, the helpful team at Lowcountry Ace is always ready to assist. We’re here in Charleston, James Island, and Folly Beach to ensure you have everything you need for a safe and enjoyable outdoor experience.

Search Lowcountry Ace

Visit us for all your grilling and hardware needs!

eMail
Facebook
LinkedIn
Reddit
StumbleUpon
X

Lowcountry Links

Carrie Hegenderfer profile pictureCarrie Hegenderfer
15:07 10 Apr 25
This Ace Hardware store is not really close to my house but I came here after having a poor experience at the Johns Island Ace. I was greeted by friendly employees upon entry and throughout my experience, asked if I needed help, the store atmosphere was cheerful and in organized condition, and they had absolutely no problem exchanging an item purchased at another Ace Hardware for a few other items from their store. I even spent extra money in store. I will drive the extra mileage to come to this store moving forward.
Response from the owner 16:10 10 Apr 25
Thank you so much for sharing your experience, Carrie! We’re delighted to hear that our friendly staff and cheerful atmosphere made your visit worthwhile, and that we could help with your item exchange. We’re here to serve the Charleston community with quality and dedication, and we look forward to welcoming you back to Lowcountry Ace Hardware for your future needs!
Anita Praytor profile pictureAnita Praytor
14:14 26 Mar 25
Visited Sunday afternoon 3/23/25. Always a pleasure to browse and shop at this Ace store. A man, Steve, around 4-430 totally helped me in the name of Customer Service. He cut chain for me that isn't sold separately for a hanging basket. Bigger, he followed me to checkout with a bag of soil weighing a ton. Steve insisted I bring my SUV parked in far-away Publix Land so he could lift it out of cart into my SUV. Wouldn't budge on who was moving the soil into the SUV! Thank you again, Steve! Anita
Response from the owner 15:45 14 Apr 25
Thank you, Anita, for sharing your delightful experience with us! We’re so glad to hear that Steve went above and beyond to assist you with cutting chain and helping with your bag of soil. At Lowcountry Ace Hardware, our team is always dedicated to making your visit as pleasant as possible. If you ever need further assistance, don’t hesitate to come back and see us!
Stephen Houmard profile pictureStephen Houmard
19:45 23 Jan 25
GREAT SERVICE! The older guys know everything!
Good Bye Lowes!
Response from the owner 20:00 23 Jan 25
Thank you so much for your enthusiastic review, Stephen! We're delighted to hear you received great service and that our experienced team could assist you. We're grateful for the opportunity to be your go-to hardware store in Charleston, and we look forward to helping you with any future projects!
Billy Erickson profile pictureBilly Erickson
22:34 26 Nov 24
All the employees I encountered were so helpful and friendly. The store is very clean.
Response from the owner 15:45 14 Apr 25
Thank you so much for your positive feedback, Billy! We’re so glad to hear that our helpful and friendly team, along with our clean store environment, made your visit enjoyable. Thank you for choosing Lowcountry Ace Hardware, and we look forward to assisting you with any of your future needs!
Lauren Carter profile pictureLauren Carter
18:39 11 Jul 24
Thad is the man— he saw our look of confusion in the paint aisle, immediately offered help, and even mixed the paint for us. So impressed by his customer service, we’ll definitely be back in the future!
Response from the owner 17:00 13 Aug 24
Thank you so much for the kind words, Lauren! We're thrilled to hear that Thad could assist you and make your experience enjoyable. We look forward to serving you again soon!
Brad Flaig profile pictureBrad Flaig
16:27 06 Jul 24
We love Ace! So helpful to not have to compete against the beach traffic or the Lowe’s traffic. This store is brand new, everyone is so helpful and the location is convenient
Photo from customer reviewPhoto from customer review
Response from the owner 20:00 09 Jul 24
Thanks for the wonderful review, Brad! We're thrilled to hear that you find our location convenient and enjoy our helpful staff. We look forward to serving you again!
Restora profile pictureRestora
16:11 08 Apr 24
Lovely! Has everything I always need and great customer service.
Response from the owner 15:10 28 May 24
Thank you so much for your kind words, Restora! We're delighted to hear you found everything you needed and enjoyed our customer service. Looking forward to helping you again!
Warren Weber profile pictureWarren Weber
12:20 01 Apr 24
Nice selection of merchandise, people are friendly, reasonable prices
Response from the owner 15:10 28 May 24
Thank you for the great review, Warren! We're thrilled to hear you enjoyed our selection, friendly staff, and reasonable prices. Looking forward to seeing you again at Lowcountry Ace Hardware!
Kat T profile pictureKat T
16:43 29 Mar 24
Frank approached is within seconds of entering into the plumbing aisle, he carried us throughout the store, getting the correct fittings to put us back in business. Thanks Frank!.
Response from the owner 15:10 28 May 24
Thank you for the awesome review, Kat! We’re thrilled to hear that Frank was able to assist you so effectively and get everything you needed. We appreciate your kind words!
Rhonda Jones profile pictureRhonda Jones
21:27 27 Mar 24
Steve Thad ,and Renee the customer service person were awesome and assisted me so much with my DIY project.If you want great advice and truly kind helpful staff please give them a chance to be of assistance. All the staff there were warm,friendly, and helpful. Thanks so much I appreciate ? yall.
Joshua Johnson profile pictureJoshua Johnson
12:48 14 Oct 23
Manager wouldn’t return money to my credit card despite having the same card and rewards number (no receipt), so gift card only. I was told “I’d have to look it up in the computer, it’s tedious”

After talking to other customers, I learned it’s routine to return with same credit card or rewards account.
C D profile pictureC D
20:58 30 Mar 23
This location is the best. They are attentive and professional and always aim to please. We ordered a grill from them which was delivered quickly. There was a slight defect and they immediately rectified the situation and went above and beyond on multiple aspects of the transaction. Everyone from the GM to the delivery guys and everyone in between are always so great. We will continue to give them our business ?!
CALL LOWCOUNTRY ACE